Preliminary notes on a paintball industry story – or, Paintball (As I Knew It) is Dead

I played paintball competitively for four years or so, and I stopped right as things were getting very bad. It was kind of hard to notice the state of the industry, being that players from Regina, Saskatchewan are cloistered in a way that keeps most news from ever showing up at the door. That, and there was no real recession in Saskatchewan – we kept up a high growth rate pretty much the whole way through.

What I did pick up on, though, was the slow death of the tournament scene. There was one league that did well in Saskatchewan; suddenly, in 2007, the number and size of its divisions shrank, and nowadays, it frequently cancels events due to low registration.

I know the last little chunk of info because this summer I tried to cover the tournament scene to which I used to proudly belong. The event was cancelled. The field owner suggested instead that I come up for the grand-scale military-themed “scenario game” that would be held the next day. All the scenarios I’ve been to are now bigger than the tournaments I used to attend.

What made speedball die?
It turns out that the incredibly polarized world of mid-2000’s paintball was really just hubris. The huge growth of the flashy speedball/tournament segment made it fashionable to mock the bushballers who were stuck in the woods, wearing camouflage, shooting mechanically-operated guns. Behind all this was a relentless technological forward-march: there was an arms race that started with the first electronic gun, and it keeps going today, despite some efforts to lessen balls-per-second rates in competitive tournaments. Basically, it meant that at the higher levels of tournament play, you could shoot a case of paint in just over two minutes – that’s 2000 paintballs in 133 seconds – and it priced so many people out of the game that it’s amazing no one saw a collapse coming.

Some companies got overextended and – even after expanding their lines to capture the scenario segment – collapsed, like Smart Parts (ironically, they produced the very first electro-pneumatic marker, the Shocker). Economies of scale never really met demand at the same scale, and you’ll notice that there are now few Wal-Marts that still sell paintball gear (for they have noticed higher growth in other military-simulation games like airsoft). The smart view on this whole phenomenon is that paintball got caught up in a model that did not make any sense for retaining customers, and the parallels to other industries – and the economy at large – are there to be made. Neat. Hopefully I will do a bit of that in a bigger article, but here’s a bit of a teaser: selling high rate-of-fire guns at an intro price is a bit like a subprime loan. You can keep going on it until the payment balloons – and for so many people, this happened far before the recession started. In 2005, paintball was losing players in the middle of the strongest period of economic growth in a very long time. Why? Because if you couldn’t afford to pay the exorbitant costs associated with operating a high rate-of-fire electro-pneumatic marker, then you would be shot sooner, more frequently, at higher velocities, and at closer ranges than ever before. Indeed, that held true even if you did own the fastest, newest gear: the sport itself got so fast and intense that it was finally starting to live up to the “extreme” title that it was being marketed under. Paintball seemed to make its own Milgram experiment, with the consumers egging each other on to dispense more and more pain – both physically and financially. I still don’t know why, but the whole industry was beholden to this gambit. Shooting more paint, it turns out, destroyed speedball, or so I hope to argue.


4 thoughts on “Preliminary notes on a paintball industry story – or, Paintball (As I Knew It) is Dead

  1. Well wrote article Andrew, I believe you hit the nail on the head. I do disagree on one point, paintball never lost it’s appeal too me. life just got in the way; school, buying a house, getting married… Like you said, it all comes down to money. I still get out and practice when I can, even playing an event this year. And I still enjoy every minute and dollar of it.

    • Thanks a ton Morgan (I totally recognize that e-mail address). I totally understand, and I find myself waiting for the right time to get back into things a bit. I was scoping out the new Empire pump… maybe it’s time to try that side of the sport again!

  2. Good analysis. I like that last bit… “Shooting more paint, it turns out, destroyed speedball.” Interesting concept.

    I would love to play as much as I used to, but like Morgan said, there are other things that I need to spend that money on. Life gets in the way of having fun I guess…

    I played a tournament here in Kelowna in August 2010 and it was a great time. But I think the same thing is going on here, some of the events this summer were cancelled due to lack of participation. It all comes down to money. Paintball is just not where people want to spend their disposable income (if they have any.)

    I was sad to see the PSL events cancelled this year. I was really looking forward to the Saskatchewanderer’s coverage.

    • I was looking forward to it too! Hell, even my boss was really excited about it.

      I think the money thing’s a big part of it. Kyle said on facebook that it just became so much work to do one event – and then there’s the fact that we got older, and had to spend money on other things. It became tough to pull off. I figure that, on a larger scale, if people were already discouraged by how much they were spending on the sport, then they probably would’ve stopped all together when the reecssion started.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s